Musings on Wisconsin, Wages, and the Economy


I am not a personal fan of labor unions. I understand the need for them, but with today’s regulations, are they truly needed to ensure fair pay and working conditions? What are fair working conditions for teachers?  A class room.  I can see a need to ensure that there are no weapons brought into the classroom, but if the unions are the ones that are insisting on this instead of the parents, we have a whole new set of problems.  As for pay, the average teacher in Wisconsin makes $48,000 a year. Considering how an average a teacher will not work more that 200 days a year according to their contract, this comes out to $30 an hour. If this is considered unfair pay, then I want unfair pay too. I could use the raise.

I think that the way that the Republicans are going about this is not right, but I do think that union and government employees are a little out of touch with the way the global economy works. Businesses are in place to make money for the owners. If it doesn’t make money, then why operate a business. Governments should not make money but they should not be in debt either. If revenue can not cover the operating expenses, operating expenses must be lowered. This means that wages and benefits might be frozen or decreased in order to ensure the continued operation of the entity. Those of us in the private sector understand this all to well. If you do not agree with not getting a raise, you look for employment elsewhere.

Car manufactures are a great example of why union wages are not practical. Detroit is almost in ruin due to the unemployment rate from when the Big 3 ran into problems. Those companies are functioning again and making money, but the majority of their operations are now in right to work states. The wages are lower there and the companies can better compete with foreign manufactures that use cheaper labor. It is sad to see so many people lose their jobs, but when starting janitors were making $19 + an hour, you can easily how the pay levels demanded by unions were out of touch with the global economy.

If you think this is unfair, let me ask you to look at your own spending habits. Do you buy the most expensive items at the store? When you go to buy a car, do you pay the list price or do you negotiate for a lower price? Would you spend an extra $20,000 for a house when the same house is for sale right next to it at a lower price?

Jobs are flooding out of this country to places where labor costs are cheaper. Now to offset this, the government should give tax breaks to those companies that employee domestic workers instead of taking jobs overseas. Offset the opportunity cost that a business takes by hiring locally. At the same time, businesses should be treating employees fairly. Fair wages and benefits should be offered. If they are not, the employees should leave the company and it will eventually fail due to its own greed.

The spectacle in Wisconsin is a sad sight and the real issues are being buried under political rhetoric and hurt feelings.

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Misc, Politics

2 responses to “Musings on Wisconsin, Wages, and the Economy

  1. “Car manufactures are a great example of why union wages are not practical. Detroit is almost in ruin due to the unemployment rate from when the Big 3 ran into problems” (Xander)

    Uhm, you might want to consider free trade agreements as the death toll for the big 3. What happened, and this is all historically verifiable, was the market for outsourcing production opened up in countries like China and India and made it tonnes of times cheaper to produce cars and ship them back to the USA for much cheaper than making them here.

    This resulted in cheaper prices for the cars themselves, why exactly? The production lines in China were getting paid something like .13 cents an hour as compared to our minimum wage which may have been 5.00/hour at the time. If you think of the overall savings on a vehicle wil some 300+ parts – we are talking quite a bit of profit for the owners and savings for the customer.

    The reason America and the West are losing their jobs is because the richest people in those big companies have found a way to exploit other markets and hire their workers, not ours. So eventually, the stay competitive with other car companies, you up and move the whole thing to another country because it is even cheaper to do ot that way – since those foreign govt’s are hurting for the addition to their economy…they offer some nice incentives.

    Jobs left because, and this is true in many sectors of production, we can’t pay people like they’re slaves in the West – something like .80 cents/hour – which is what occurs in China for example. How can anyone that produces anything and wants to reach a large global economy produce it here? This is the problem and neither party ever addresses it.

  2. The principal is still the same. Unable to compete due to union wage requirements, the manufactures have moved to places where unions can not dictate wages and benefits while threatening to shut down production.

    Due to sports and certain promotion features, some vehicles have to be made in the country. You can see many of those being made in the southern states though where Right to Work dominates.

    You can not force other countries to pay what you consider is a fair wage. Governments address this with import taxes, but our exports are inflated even higher in response.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s